Our text today comes right after a couple disciples learn that Jesus has been resurrected. Jesus was killed and now Jesus is alive and walking around. Today we learn how the rest of the disciples including Thomas come to hear that Jesus is in fact not dead but living. Let’s remember the last time the disciples were with Jesus- in the upper room sharing a meal as friends- only days ago when all seemed calm and normal as far as they were concerned because they didn’t understand what Jesus was trying to communicate to them. Judas had already made a deal to betray Jesus. At that meal, Jesus tells them that he will be betrayed by someone else aka Peter and now here we see that Thomas still doesn’t believe what Jesus has prophesied. It’s only been a few days and things are a hot mess. A lot has happened. Some are stunned, some are amazed, some are feeling immense guilt and shame, and some are still in disbelief. This story is famously known as the doubting Thomas- he wasn’t with the group that physically saw Jesus so when they come and tell him what they have seen he is skeptical. It’s not until he actually touches the parts of Jesus body that we’re speared that he believes. This part is interesting that it’s even in here- it seems like maybe having a way to physically prove He was Jesus was essential. There’s technically no reason why at the crucifixion Jesus was pierced in the sides. It seems to me the for the sake of the narrative that the fact that Jesus pierced sides show up again is to teach us something or why have it be part of the story? Maybe God knows we need proof. I know Thomas gets the raw end of the deal for not being able to believe without sight- to have a blind faith but at the same time Jesus openly gives Thomas proof- he doesn’t try and deny Thomas the joy of knowing that He is alive just because Thomas needed a little bit more and it seems like Jesus created a way for Thomas to believe. Judas wasn’t ashamed to demand more information, he didn’t apologize. He didn’t have to ask and could have just not cared enough to really want to believe, or he could have just said he believed. He was courageous in asking Jesus to show him the truth and he was courageous in pronouncing Jesus as his lord and his God. I don’t think Thomas is in this narrative to shame him and try to get us to not be like him. I think Thomas is in here because we are like him. One theologian pointed out that Thomas means “the twin” and we actually never hear of his twin- maybe the twin is us. More than ever as a human race we want proof. We live in a culture where people are constantly trying to scam us by phone or e-mail and through hacking. We’d be naïve not to want proof.
God knows this and seems to say okay I can help those of you who have trouble believing- we will find a way for you to believe. And I think for all of us that is in a unique way. Jesus relates to us uniquely so how I come to believe in God will be different than how each one of you do.
At the risk of sounding like a hippie or overly politically correct, I’m going to refer to God as goodness for the rest of the sermon. When we talk about believing in God we can’t help ourselves but get lost in what that means because it’s impossible for us to know what that means in its entirety. But we are told in scripture that God is good and God represents goodness so for today and for the sake of helping us understand God in a way that is plausible let us think of God as goodness. Do you believe in goodness? What keeps you from believing in goodness? Are you willing to fight to believe in goodness?
I don’t consider myself foolish although a lot of people would say being a pastor is foolish work to spend your life doing. I don’t adhere to blind faith or some abstract being that does miraculous things. Can I answer all questions- no, do I doubt yes. But what I know is that I do encounter beauty As many people do but where faith is involved is that I choose to believe that that beauty is a gift for humans. I have felt love and I choose to believe it’s a gift for humans. I have felt grace and I choose to believe it is a gift for humans. Same goes with all the other things I encounter- all things I’m going to call goodness. How they came about, I’m not sure- I don’t know that it matters but I have faith that it’s not an accident and that we are worthy of all these things. Maybe it’s foolish to think so highly of us to believe that love and grace and restoration are here as a gift to us- but the alternative makes no sense to me. For such purpose driven beings for there to be no purpose to any of it just doesn’t fit. So because I believe in goodness, I fight to continue to believe in it when the doubt creeps in. I’ve heard people say “I’ve seen too much bad stuff to believe in a purpose or reason for us being here”. I say that I’ve seen too much good stuff not to believe that there is a reason or purpose for us being here. I see the bad stuff too, but it doesn’t discount the good stuff I see.
I just finished reading a book called all the ugly and wonderful things. I’m not going to recommend it unless you want to read a really complicated book about love and family and like scripture end up with more questions than answers. It makes you think and question and is uncomfortable for much of the book. The hard part of this book is this young girl, wavy finds love and hope in a very unexpected place. In an unexpected person. In a way society would not approve of. The whole book the author causes you to go back and forth between whether this love is right or wrong or more than that asks the question, what is love? Can it be wrong if it’s love? What makes love love? If this thing makes you feel whole- helps you heal, isn’t it good? Can one type of love turn into another type of love. In the book the young girl who becomes a young woman finds healing and wholeness in a way that is frankly uncomfortable. But despite all the really horrible trauma she faced in her first 12 years of life, she finds a lot of beauty. The bad doesn’t keep her from seeing the good and she fights over and over to keep the good. She saw a glimpse of good in something and she will bet everything she has on it.
Thomas wants to believe in goodness, I want to believe in goodness, wavy wants to believe in goodness. But you have to fight for it. You have to ask hard questions, work out all of your doubt, choose to put stock in the slivers of beauty you encounter, you have to fight for the good things to be present in your life. Goodness shows up differently for everyone- what does goodness look like in your life?
I don’t think there’s anything wrong with us that we need to fight to believe in it- we’ve all been through a lot and have many reasons to doubt. There’s nothing wrong with being Thomas
I know Jesus says blessed are those who didn’t need to see, didn’t need the proof. But what about those of us that have had our trust broken or been deceived or hurt- why is it so crazy that we would need proof. For many of us, It’s a form of self-protection. I think everyone wished we lived in a world where we didn’t need to protect ourselves, but we don’t live in that world. I get it Jesus is saying he is different- maybe you cant trust them but you can trust me but we need help doing this.
Thomas displays courage here- courage to ask the hard questions, to voice his doubt- he’s not ashamed. And then he has the courage to pronounce that Jesus is his lord and his God.
What kept Thomas from believing was not knowing if Jesus actually resurrected. Maybe this isn’t your question- maybe you are not concerned as much with this answer. So I would ask you what keeps you from believing in Goodness? Is it having been taught a narrow definition of what goodness Is? it how unrealistic the stories in the Bible are? Is it all the violence and pain you see in the world?
I know many if not all of you have asked yourselves these questions before and have come up empty. I wonder though if we are asking them the wrong way. When we ask these big doubting questions, we ask them abstractly. We ask them in a hypothetical way- not a way like Thomas where its personal and circumstantial. I wonder if we were to ask these big doubt questions about the things concerning our personal lives what kind of answers would we get?. I don’t believe the question of why does God let bad things happen to good people is any different than why is my child in pain, my spouse, my dog, myself? If we want to know who God is then we have to start with what’s happening to us personally. We have to voice our own doubts- am I loveable? Am I likeable? Am I smart enough? Am I beautiful? Am I trustworthy? Am I worthy? Am I a good… fill in the blank- daughter, mother, sister, friend, husband, pet owner. We will not find God in the abstract. We will find God in these questions- and we will not find God in the answers but it is in the asking that we find God. You find your faith when you realized you believed enough to ask the question.
I was once asked a question in an interview of what did I believe had to be true about the gospel story in order for God to be real… I knew this person and they were trying to trick me not in a there’s a right answer way but in a there isn’t a right answer way- to me personally, I’m not concerned with what did or didn’t happen- I’m concerned with do I believe in love, justice, goodness, mercy, the power of forgiveness, grace. Do I believe in these things and if I do what in my life has me doubting them at times?
What questions can I be courageous enough to ask to restore my faith time and time again? See with Thomas- he wanted to believe, he was just having trouble- he wanted the glimpses of faith to become stronger and stronger but he needed reassurance. He wouldn’t have asked these hard questions if he didn’t want these things to be true. Do you believe in goodness enough to fight to keep believing in when you see things that cause you to doubt? If not, what keeps you from believing in it? Is it enough to discount all the goodness you do see? How much goodness is enough to believe in? Earlier I said we would find faith not in the answers but in the questions- the point is not getting an answer- the point is that you care enough to ask the question. That tells you where your belief lies right there. Amen.